Monday, December 09, 2013

Old and new MySQL verbosity

I was pleased to see Morgan’s announcement about a fix to an old problem of mine. In March 2012 I complained about MySQL verbosity during installation.

In MySQL 5.7.3, this behavior was changed. While the default is still as loud as it can, you can now add an option (log_error_verbosity) to send only errors to STDERR, which allows you to hide the output of mysql_install_db, and still get the errors, if they occur.

Well done!

However, the same obnoxious verbosity is also in MariaDB 10.0.x. Since I discussed this specific bug with a few MariaDB developers early in 2012, I was disappointed to see this same output when running mysql_install_db with MariaDB. Here’s the same appeal: MariaDB developers, please fix this usability issue!

And now, for the laughing notes. All versions of MySQL available now, from Oracle, Percona, MariaDB, list this line when installing with mysql_install_db:

Please report any problems with the './scripts/mysqlbug' script!

There is Bug#29716 that was reported in 2008, about mysqlbug being unnecessary (by then, it had been obsolete for 2 or 3 years already), with a patch submitted but not committed. So, in 2013, we still see a reference to a tool that has ceased working for at least 8 years. It should not take much to remove this line and replace it with an appropriate link to the bugs system.


Terje Rosten said...

> Please report any problems with the './scripts/mysqlbug' script!

Please have a look at the rpms from MySQL Yum Repos and get a surprise :-)

Baron Schwartz said...

My bug report would be "delete and replace that broken installation script" :-)

Unknown said...

Bug#29716 has been fixed in 5.6.16 (to be released).

Vote on Planet MySQL